Jonathan Wellington, a Partner at Watkins and Gunn Solicitors,
considers the latest developments in the law relating of self-
defence at your home
The phrase that your home is your castle has come to the fore
recently after a Mr Vincent Cook was cleared of any wrongdoing
following the stabbing of a burglar at his home and the
Government's announcement that the law needs clarification through
new legislation.
The law states that you may use "reasonable force" to protect
yourself or another, your property or to prevent crime or to assist
in the arrest of an offender. Reasonable force is defined as "such
force as is reasonable in the circumstances".
The issue has become something of a political football. Justice
Secretary, Kenneth Clarke, has stated that householders are
entitled to use "whatever force necessary to protect themselves and
their homes". The proposed legislation, he states, would make this
"much clearer", for example, he has said that " you can hit the
burglar with the poker if he's in the house and you have a perfect
defence" but this would not extend to shooting a burglar in the
back while they are running away or getting friends together to
beat them up.
The issue is a difficult one as, even following any new
legislation, every case will still need to be judged based on its
own individual circumstances. There is certainly a move towards
greater rights for householders to defend themselves, their loved
ones and their property. However, as a note of caution, if you
overstep the mark and use excessive force you will remain liable to
criminal prosecution and a potential civil action.